Fall Convocation – Oct. 14, 2026 – Grace Lutheran, Lewiston
Matt. 22:15-22, 1 Thess. 1:1-10

Grace to you and peace from God our Father and the Lord Jesus Christ. Amen.
Is it possible for us to compartmentalize our lives in a way that gives God a compartment? This question is at the heart of today’s Matthew text. The reading tells the story of the first of three attempts by the religious leaders to entrap Jesus and discredit him with others.
The question of paying taxes to Rome was a thorny one in Jesus’ day. The opponents this time are the Pharisees and Herodians, an unusual pairing. You know the context. The Herodians were comprised of supporters of the Herodian rulers. The Pharisees were of course the devout Jews who tried to be as faithful to the law as they possibly could be.
When they asked Jesus whether it was “lawful to pay taxes to the emperor or not,” they thought they might trap him into saying something offensive, either about the Romans or about his Jewish faith. If Jesus said no, it is not lawful to pay the Roman tax, he would be aligned with the rebellious minority and offend the Romans. If he were to say yes, it is lawful, his loyalty to the Jews would be questioned.
Jesus asks to see a coin and then asks whose inscription was on it. A denarius of that time would have had the image of the Roman emperor’s head, along with the inscription, “Tiberius Caesar, son of the Divine Augustus.” Jesus’ opponents replied that the inscription was of the emperor. Then came the response that settled the matter: “Give therefore to the emperor the things that are the emperor’s and to God the things that are God’s.”
In many ways, this is a nonanswer. The Pharisees and Herodians are left to wrestle with their own questions, as are we. Don’t put a period where God would put a comma. God is still speaking. That was a holy envy shout-out to our United Church of Christ colleagues, who often use a comma as a symbol. Yes, God is still speaking. Dorothy Day once said of this gospel, “If we were to render unto God all the things which are God’s, there would be nothing left for Caesar.” There’s some holy envy for our Catholic siblings and one of their modern saints.
So, let’s wrestle together with this text. One scholar [Warren Carter] said that an imperial tax can be paid without the payment being a vote of support for Rome. Paying taxes acknowledges Rome’s political power but not its moral authority to rule. That moral authority belongs to God. Which is why Jesus quickly adds that one must pay to God the things that are due to God. How do we work this out? Is Jesus giving us an ethic?
I won’t make you raise your hands, but I know many of us are struggling with the Portico increase this year. We know that not paying Portico for health benefits will not solve the healthcare crisis in our country. Further, the Portico pool of shared benefits works as a pool. Still, that pool is not universal healthcare as it could be. We continue to advocate for healthcare for all. And our whole predicament reminds us that Jesus’ vision of the Sermon on the Mount is not a reality yet.
Like me, you might be getting constant reminders of our upcoming election. I find myself wanting to put so much hope in our democracy. And yet I know that no election results will be salvific. Yet we continue the work for full participation of the electorate, working for all voices to be heard at the ballot box. We live in this tension–being in the world while always holding a vision for what could be. Before we feast at the table today, we will pray together “Your kingdom come.”
Last week, as part of our CaSTLE Grant from Wartburg Seminary, I traveled to Indianapolis for the rural and small-town ministry project gathering. The theme of the event was program evaluation. We wrestled with yet another problem. The metrics of unchecked capitalism have been adopted by the church so that people talk of God blessing churches with money. We, in this room, know the prosperity gospel is not the Good News. And at the same time, we know evaluation still has value. And everyone in the room in Indianapolis absolutely wanted to recognize and celebrate where the gospel is proclaimed well (see Augsburg Confession Article 5).
The only way I can sleep at night wrestling with all of this, is that I am not alone. The Holy Spirit is with us. In our story, Jesus did not have coin, but those questioning him did. They were carrying around a coin with a graven image on it. When I get caught up in the wrestling and start gazing at idols, you all are my witnesses, pointing me back to Jesus Christ. As Paul wrote to the Thessalonians,
9 For they report about us what kind of welcome we had among you and how you turned to God from idols to serve a living and true God 10 and to wait for his Son from heaven, whom he raised from the dead—Jesus, who rescues us from the coming wrath.
I know you struggle in the systems; you claim the identity of being both saint and sinners. But I see you servants of the gospel witnessing to the love and mercy of Jesus Christ week in and week out; helping your communities of faith do the same, never perfectly, never fully. We keep praying, “Your kingdom come.”
And here’s the truth. A coin carries the image of an earthly ruler, but all of worship reminds us, as Pastor Leila said several times this week, of the deeper identity that shapes our lives: you belong to God. Quoting Howard Thurman again, “As bearers of the Imago Dei, we each hold expression of God within us that has never existed before us and will not exist again after us.” You are bearers of the Imago Dei.
And if that were not enough, although it is, you have the image of the cross of Christ imprinted on your forehead in Holy Baptism. You were sealed by the Holy Spirit and marked with the Cross of Christ forever.
When I am outside our synod, I often say that here in the Mountain West, because all the mainline denominations are religious minorities, we swim in deep ecumenical waters. This has led me to revisit The World Council of Churches historic 1982 document, written at the gathering in Lima, Peru: Baptism, Eucharist and Ministry, the foundation for all our full-communion agreements and so much of our ecumenical work. Hear these words of promise and liberation, “God bestows upon all baptized persons the anointing and the promise of the Holy Spirit, marks them with a seal and implants in their hearts the first instalment of their inheritance as [children] of God.” Amen.


































